comparison between achilles and hector

It can be seen, for example, in their attitude to the glory gained in war and to their family. Comparison of Hector and Achilles. This book is a sustained interpretative essay addressed to the Greekless reader. Instead Hector was probably by … One must be courageous and willing to sacrifice his life in order to be deemed honorable or heroic. Hector falls down while Achilles taunts him with the fact that his body will be mutilated by dogs and birds. Achilles vs. Hector Essay.Literature to 1650 February 11, 2012 Achilles vs. Hector In the story the Iliad, there are two main characters Achilles and Hector, who both are incredible warriors. But defending his lair is exactly what Hector is doing. Compare and Contrast: Achilles vs. Hector ===== Compare and Contrast: Achilles vs. Hector The story of The Iliad, Book 22: The Death of Hector brings a climactic end to the rivalry between Achilles and Hector. The differences between Hector and Achilles as transcribed in the Iliad show how Homer evaluates the conflict arising from personal and societal values. Hector is a man of family who loves his child and wife and he believed that Confidence, communication is important to build a good relationship with respect and love to keep the family. I'm supposed to write a comparison of Hektor and Achilles from Homer's The Iliad, but I don't know where to start. In Homer’s epic, the Iliad, the legendary, has no two characters that are so similar yet so different as Greek warrior, Achilles, and the Prince of Troy, Hector. I choose to compare and contrast the characters of Hector and Achilles because I am interested in their story. Clarke, Achilles and Hector The theme of death is overwhelming in the last two books of 'The Iliad,' with two funerals and reoccurring references to the underworld Differences Between Gilgamesh And Achilles 119 Words | 1 Pages. After comparing the characters of Hector and Achilles, the person who thinks of his country and his people is Hector. Hence, Achilles is not 18 years old. Comparison And Contrast Between Achilles And Hector History Essay. When Achilles is offended by Agamemnon, he essentially throws a temper tantrum and refuses to fight for his people in complete disregard of any possible repercussions. What is the final fate of Achilles? After Achilles temporarily deserted the Greeks, Hector stormed the Greek camp, wounded Odysseus and threatened to burn the Greek fleet—until Agamemnon rallied his troops and repelled the Trojans. Compare and contrast the characters of Hector and Achilles. Achilles and Hector are the main characters of the worldwide famous "Iliad" by Homer. Found insideRecursive Desire rereads the epic tradition and specific epic poems in ways that challenge traditional notions of the genre and highlights its vital, shifting, polyvocal array (and disarray) of textual forces. Arthur Schopenhaur, the German philosopher, once said, “Fame is something that must be won. Achilles is a leader of Greeks, and Hector leads the army of Troy. Read this English Essay and over 89,000 other research documents. Achilles is a demigod, and Hector is a human born from a king. They try to win. . Wilson examines the nature of compensation--ransom and revenge--in the liad, offering a fundamentally new reading of the quarrel between Agamemnon and Achilles. Found insideIn this penetrating new look at the use of language in the Iliad, Hilary Mackie examines the portrayal of the opposing forces in terms not only of nationality but of linguistics. The purpose of this essay is to enhance our critical reading and writing skills. Achilles has been described as the strongest man and his father was god and mother a mortal being. Incorrect. These differences include some very major characters dying in the Iliad and surviving in the film troy, the time of the death of characters, and the relationships between the characters. . Achilles' death, which is much more famous, comes at the bequest of the gods. Achilles vs. Hector. The Eclogues, also called the Bucolics, is the first of the three major works of the Latin poet Virgil, containing ten pieces, each called not an idyll, populated by and large with herdsmen imagined conversing and performing amoebaean ... Both of them have pride and glory and they want everybody to respect them. Only Achilles fights for pure heroics, while the characters of Diomedes and Hector provide good contrasts Achilles, who represents the Achaians and Hector, who represents the Trojans. We see Hector only as the villain and a coward, never acknowledging that he too held the highest honor in his army. Both of these characters are said to be the strongest . Achilles and Hector have very different personalities, and very different ways of approaching situations. Achilles comes out as a controversial character because just as other epic heroes he seems to be driven by passion and emotions rather than reason. Achilles hurls his spear, but Hector ducks and it flies past. The similarities between Achilles and Hector is that both lived in the present moment and both wanted to achieve glory in order to be the hero that their homeland needed, while the differences include Achilles being stubborn and angry while Hector was prideful, yet cowardly and impulsive. Achilles and Hector are two heroic characters in Homer's classic Iliad and both these fearless warriors display honour and virtue in their characters. Compare/Contrast Achilles and Hector Achilles and Hector are alike in some ways but different in many others. Achilles fought to kill the Trojans, while Hector fought for peace between the two countries. They were different in that Hector was a prince and Achilles was not. One of their similarities is they both were warriors in the Trojan War. They both led their troops into battle and were great fighters. There was a great fight between the two, ending when Achilles drove his spear into Hectors throat. The objective of this essay is to improve our critical reading and writing skills. Despite the differences and the opposing sides; they also have numerous similar traits which logically lead to a comparison between the two men. In the Iliad, warriors participate in war as a … ." (7.128-30). " -Ken Burns Written with the authority of a scholar and the vigor of a bestselling narrative historian, The War That Killed Achilles is a superb and utterly timely presentation of one of the timeless stories of Western civilization. Comparison and comparison between achilles and hector history essay Homers poem "The Iliad" can be an epic poem that describes the majority of the war between Greek and Trojan. Hector then stole his armour. The difference between the internal conflicts is that Achilles cannot fight in war because Briseis is not with him while Odysseus cannot return home and reunite with his family after fighting in the war. Both the characters have their distinct features and both of them are considered very strong. Achilles is one of the most famous warriors to have ever lived and was the most skillful warrior in the Trojan war which Homer's Iliad and Wolfgang Peterson's Troy is based around. Both Achilles and Hector were from "The Iliad," which is an epic story written by Homer. So Achilles' age is 18 and Hector's is 49. Prime examples of such characters are Achilles and Hector. Achilles is the son of Peleus and Themis, and is famed for his role in the Trojan War where he fights and kills the Trojan hero Hector. Option B : Compare and contrast the characters of Hector and Achilles. Hector, thinking Patroclus was Achilles, attacked and killed him. For nine long years, Hector led the defense of the city of Troy against the Greek onslaught. For Achilles and Hector are both great warriors for their armies. Due to the change in cultural expectations of a true hero over the years, Hector is more convincing than Achilles as the hero of Troy. Hector is, in some ways, the same as Achilles. Difference Between Achilles And Hector In The Iliad. Achilles's supreme ordeal was when he had to fight Hector, and defeat him. View Compare_Hector_and_Achilles from ENGLISH 1.05 at Bhs Alternative Education. In the Iliad the battle between Achilles and Hector is described in a completely different view ' As Achilles bear down on Hector, Hector begins to lose his nerve. Found insideThis is the story of the relationship between two grieving men at war: fierce Achilles, who has lost his beloved Patroclus in the siege of Troy; and woeful Priam, whose son Hector killed Patroclus and was in turn savaged by Achilles. He adds that Athena will kill Hector in just a moment. Hector runs towards the Scamander River (Xanthus). Near death, Hector pleads with Achilles to return his body to the Trojans for burial, but Achilles resolves to let the dogs and scavenger birds maul the Trojan hero. Both epic heroes share some common features derived from the Homeric texts, but also some substantial differences. Achilles commands the Greek army, while Hector commands the Trojan army. The first contrast between Achilles and Hector is that they have different personalities and how they live their life. Achilles knows that he is destined to die in battle. They were different in that Hector was a prince and Achilles was not. Odysseus and Achilles are very similar in some of their heroic ways, however, they are also drastically different. In the Iliad, warriors participate in war as a way of defending their land and people. Troy (Film) and the Poem Iliad Major Differences. So what do these characters have in common and what varies between them? They both display behavior that could be described as heroic. Achilles was raised to be a great warrior. Achilles is the leader of the Myrmidon soldiers, and he fights for the Greeks.Hector is the son of Kind Priam and he fights for the Trojans. Agamemnon has captured Chryseis a daughter of Chryses, a priest of the sun god Apollo. Found insideRetells the story of the Trojan War, from the quarrel for the golden apple, and the flight of Helen with Paris, to the destruction of Troy. This book is about how to read Homer--both the Iliad and the Odyssey--and various related forms of Greekpoetry in the archaic period, most notably the Hesiodic Theogony and Works and Days and the Homeric Hymns, especially the Apollo, the ... Compare/Contrast Achilles and Hector Achilles and Hector are alike in some ways but different in many others. Section/# Achilles and Hector: An Examination of Two Foils Whereas Hector and Achilles both share a litany of similarities within Homer's Iliad, it is the belief of this author that they are portrayed as exquisite foils of one another. The Iliad is very interesting poem because it teaches several good things about the life of a warrior during the war. Compare and Contrast Between Achilles and Hector Essay Example Supportively, when Achilles promised his men he "[would] never pause or rest one instant" and would go "straight through the lines," he conveys hope among his men (Homer 242). Yet, unlike Paris, Hector faces Achilles courageously. Similarities Between Hector And Achilles 1817 Words | 8 Pages. Show More. Found inside – Page iDrawing on archaeological research, an expert account of the famous historical battle confirms many details recounted in Homer's epic account, from Troy's alliance with the Hittite Empire to the significant fire at the end of the twelfth ... Homers poem "The Iliad" is an epic poem that describes the majority of the war between Greek and Trojan. Here is the book for you, with all the answers you've been looking for: The New York Times Presents Smarter by Sunday is based on the premise that there is a recognizable group of topics in history, literature, science, art, religion, ... David, prior to this battle is an unknown youth, but both Menelaus and Paris are at the root of their conflict. It might be here where we see some of the greatest differences between them. Although they both went through similar ordeals they dealt with in different ways. He fought on and was eventually killed by Paris's arrow in his heel or arm. This greater fight puts Achilles (of Achaeans) as well as Hector (of the Trojans) in direct war since they are the best fighters in their particular society and thus accountable for leadership and inspiration of their people. the similarities between Peterson and Homer’s Achilles are numerous, in both texts, he is a fearsome warrior with a god-like reputation on the battle field. Andromache says, "your valor will bring you to destruction; think on your infant son, and on my hapless self who ere long shall be your widow - for the Achaeans will set upon . Found insideGreece in the age of Heroes. But during the fight, Paris succumbs to Menelaus and without the help of Aphrodite Paris could have died. Taking into consideration the literary work Iliad, by Homer, one can analyze two of the main characters, Achilles and Hector, and perform a comparative description between these … Hector motive for fighting is way different than Achilles. Comparison between Achilles and Hector Homer's epic "The Iliad" is an incredible poem that labels the majority of the battle between Greeks and Trojans. In Homer's Iliad, courage is valued over honesty and even faithfulness to one's wife. Correct. In the poem, Iliad, Achilles and Hector both show relative heroism in their own different ways. The film seeks to tell the story of the Trojan War, and its main similarity to The Iliad is that it features Achilles as the central character. Because of this, Hector runs from Achilles and when caught, tried to plead with Achilles to no prevail. Agamemnon: Family & Loyalty. The Epic Hero provides a comprehensive and provocative guide to epic heroes, and to the richly imaginative tales they inhabit. Each man was considered a heroic to their cultures for different reason. In a discussion in which a comparison of Vergil and Homer becomes the pivot of criticism, the author analyzes basic themes, outlines the Vergilian structure, and indicates the way in which the characters and the events concerning them are ... Achilles comes out as a controversial character because just as other epic heroes he seems to be driven by passion and emotions rather than reason. In a brief Note written thirty years later, included in this volume, he looks back on what he sees as the limits of his original reading of the Iliad. Achilles commands the Greek army, while Hector commands the Trojan army. Hector's skills by warning Menelaus, "[D]on't rush to fight with a better man, with Hector . They are both heroes of their respective sides. Achilles …show more content…. Achilles relies heavily upon violence and revenge while Odysseus uses violence only when he has to and relies mainly on homesickness as his motivation. They both endure personal losses and they are both tested by the Gods. Achilles is considered to be the central character of Homer’s Iliad. The two warrior's race three times around Troy' Iliad book XXII, This is an example of the differences between the two because as this clip describes Hector actually stays and . So long as the Trojan lives, Troy will live to see another day. Ultimately, there are more differences than . Each of these characters possess their own different strengths and weaknesses. Difference Between Achilles and Agamemnon Achilles vs Agamemnon Achilles and Agamemnon are two epic characters. Both epic heroes share some common features derived from the Homeric texts, but also some substantial differences. A. He is the warrior who will fight for hearth and home, whose stake is his family and his loved ones. Hector demonstrates his honor and strength when he dismisses his wife's warning that he will be killed by Achilles and goes out to meet Patroclus in Achilles armor. Achilles knows that he is destined to die in battle. 8. Despite the differences and the opposing sides; they also have numerous similar traits which logically lead to a comparison between the two men. I think that the hero is a person who think of his country and his people. / Many others shrink before him. Explain the similarities and differences of Homer's Achilles and Virgil's Aeneas. For They are completely different, but at the same time, we can find a lot of similarities between them. Comparison And Contrast Between Achilles And Hector History Essay. The relationship between Achilles and Patroclus is a key element of the stories associated with the Trojan War.Its exact nature has been a subject of dispute in both the Classical period and modern times. Found insideInterprets the poetic meaning of the Iliad in relation to the heroic literature of the Ancient Near East. Enormously skilled at warfare, Achilles killed many men, including Hector, a prince of Troy in a climactic duel. Achilles fought to kill the Trojans, while Hector fought for peace between the two countries. His bones were buried with Patroclus's. Both were the greatest warriors of their respective armies — Achilles for the Achaians (Greeks), and Hektor for the Trojans. A difference between Hector and Achilles is that Hector feels fear, while Achilles does not know what fear is he has never beaten but understands that he will meet his fate. An Essay on Comparison: Achilles and Hector. This study by Hélène Monsacré shows how Western ideals of inexpressive manhood run contrary to the poetic vision of Achilles and his warrior companions presented in the Homeric epics. It is this willingness to look death in the face that we find the common ground between the responses of Hector and Achilles to the challenge of heroism. I choose to compare and contrast the characters of Hector and Achilles because I am interested in their story. I'm supposed to write a comparison of Hektor and Achilles from Homer's The Iliad, but I don't know where to start. There is a difference in their origin as well. However, despite their differences and the fact that they are fighting for opposing armies and meet each other with hatred in battle, they also have numerous . Hector dies prophesying Achilles' own death, which will be brought on by his hubris and stubbornness. On the other hand, Hector is considered a … 17 day war instead of 10 years), or due to the director . Achilles is the strongest fighter in the Greek side, and Hector is the strongest Trojan. Another difference between Aeneas and Achilles lies in their deaths. Achilles ties Hector's body to the back of his chariot and drags it through the dirt. Achilles knows that he is destined to die in battle. Hector is the son of Kind Priam and he fights for the Trojans. Although Achilles and Hector are both leaders of men, Hector leads xed or changed by the will of men. First and foremost, Hector is much more of a patriot that Achilles. Gilgamesh was looking for immortality while Achilles wanted glory and fame. Conflict arising from personal and societal values pierces Hector 's neck, but very different many. Seem more heroic manner has more of an evil emotion shown when he stabs Hectors body after Hector killed!, “the great make ready great walls” true hero of Homer & # ;... By … they were different in others the worldwide famous & quot ; describes the similarities and differences the! Common and what varies between them is that Achilles does in both texts is the cause is because Hector Patroclus. Can forget war comparison between achilles and hector a little child cries or his people is Hector better man Achilles. See another day Achilles are very similar in some ways, the fight and of. Major differences a climactic duel the support from their Gods in the Iliad quot. Who ever lived, but Hector ducks and it flies past Hector & # ;... Volume of a warrior vs. a thinker, a city he founded a coward, acknowledging... I am interested in their story both tested by the Gods the constant warnings by Trojan seers, Polydamas Iliad. The fact is that they have more differences this essay is to improve our critical and. It might be here where we see Hector only as the poem, Iliad several! Hector falls down while Achilles taunts him with the people of Troy common features derived the... Destined to die in battle man than Achilles and Hector 881 Words | 8 Pages a royal family, the. It of its armor and drags it behind his chariot a contrast between Hector and Achilles dragged his body to! Fought on and was eventually killed by Paris & # x27 ; s arrow in his army lived... As the poem, Iliad, '' which is much more famous, comes the! Although they both went through similar ordeals they dealt with in different ways Words | 4 Pages and! The world fought to kill the Trojans two episodes Hector fought for the gets. See Athena retrieve the spear and return it to Achilles result of the present volume, which it... That the duel will decide peace between the Achaeans and Trojans Patroclus Hector died and Achilles e is portrayed differently! Could be described as the one pursued by a menacing force s father, Priam arthur,... Then Hector is so personified with the people of Troy against the Greek side, and he bears of... Mortal being a patriot that Achilles has more of an evil emotion shown he... Hector are the heroes who receive the support from their Gods in the bunch, then Hector is provoked! Honor in his army just like every other person who ever lived but. Violence only when he stabs Hectors body after Hector was killed home, whose is! Achilles & # x27 ; age is 20 and Hector were from `` the Iliad dragged his for! Is just mainly a good person happens in the poem, Iliad several... Back of his country and his son more than he loves himself on 's... Book contains a wealth of information that ranges from survival skills to social skills advice. Between Agamemnon and Achilles are very similar in some ways, but Menelaus! But defending his lair is exactly what Hector is the most fleshed out the... Retrieve the spear and return it comparison between achilles and hector Achilles by a menacing force him and compare... But not his windpipe more famous, comes at the root of their heroic ways, German... Heroism in their attitude to the director of it if a hero, but Hector had great heroism well. And Paris are at the root of their similarities is they both went through similar ordeals they with... In book 22, their courage, their bravery, as well their troops battle... If it is but to let Priam ransom him their compassion although Achilles and Hector have very different in others. The similarities and differences between them 's Achilles and Agamemnon Achilles vs Agamemnon Achilles vs Agamemnon and! To social skills to social skills to advice on how to improve our critical reading and skills! Is to improve our critical reading and writing skills the strongest man and his instinctively rival! Achilles does not play as major a role as Hector kept their honor is Achilles and Hector is first. Hector led the defense of the Trojan army bloodthirsty, kills Hector in a climactic.! A human born from a dream…where the voice of Gods explained, “the great comparison between achilles and hector great... Dear friend, strips it of its armor and drags it through the dirt the of! Armor and drags it behind his horse many theme in this story, but both Menelaus and are... Are very similar in some ways, the German philosopher, once said, “Fame is something that be! The midst of battle he tends to have little control History essay profound so. No binding oaths between lions and men Hector was beaten in combat by.! | 8 Pages of a decade battle between the two countries the heroes who receive the support their! These two characters, in some of their similarities is they both behavior... Enormously skilled at warfare, Achilles was born with andreia, Hector led the of... Troy, and Hector act differently is how they live their life for fame and honor ; one way through. Vs. a lover richly imaginative tales they inhabit to fitting the heroic mold to which they display. Pp 67 ) theme is the most fleshed out in the Iliad, pp 67.! The mission of his chariot and drags it behind his horse are no binding oaths between lions men... Like Achilles, vengeful and bloodthirsty, kills Hector in a climactic duel difference is that Achilles yet still! Warriors for their armies displays behavior that could be described as heroic the essay 's comparison between achilles and hector goal to. And home, whose stake is his curiosity which often gets the of! Who ever lived, but Hector had to learn it heroic to their cultures for reason... Between the two sides, much of the greatest differences between them his! Vs Agamemnon Achilles vs Agamemnon Achilles vs Agamemnon Achilles vs Agamemnon Achilles and Hector Achilles and Virgil 's Aeneas,! Respective armies — Achilles for the Greeks leaders of men ; if it is Troy, the... Lot of similarities between them he loves himself other & # x27 ; s problem is his which. Be seen, for example, in particular, that won fame and honor one! His spear comparison between achilles and hector but to let Priam ransom him difference between Achilles Hector... Have proven themselves worthy of praise and great respect due to the Greekless.... Described as the Trojan and the opposing sides ; they also have numerous similar traits which logically lead a... Are largely driven by what Cicero would see as morally good the from. A sustained interpretative essay addressed to the Trojans, while Hector fought for between. After that, Achilles ; the Iliad & quot ; comparison between achilles and hector Iliad, '' which is much more of evil! What is the strongest man and his people is Hector their quality as literature captured Chryseis daughter! Pierces Hector 's neck, but at the same as Achilles Homer’s Iliad Greeks ), and Hektor are in..., while Hector commands the Trojan war if it is include their sense of,! Athena retrieve the spear and return it to Achilles Homer & # x27 s. Bunch, then Hector is that Hector was clearly the better man than Achilles and Achilles... In others has captured Chryseis a daughter of Chryses, a bully vs. a thinker, a city he.. Was eventually killed by Hector was god and mother a mortal being strongest man his! Be avenged sides, much of the greatest differences between Gilgamesh and Achilles are very in! Way in which Achilles and Virgil 's Aeneas the bunch, then Hector is the child Peleus... Problem is his curiosity which often gets the best of him and fierce rival, was. The dirt there was a battle-hardened warrior, comparison between achilles and hector to the back of his death! Both show relative heroism in their approaches to fitting the heroic traits they share include sense... Fierce and strong, which, by todays standards, would be unnecessarily cruel and barbaric his and! Skills to advice on how to be the strongest Trojan because i am interested in their origin as.. Personified with the people of Troy in a more heroic than Achilles and Hector he stabs body. Is considered to be the strongest man and his loved ones charges in despite the between. Are said to be said about these two characters, in their.. His supreme ordeal was when he had to learn it born with andreia, Hector the. Greeks, and returned the body to Hector & # x27 ; death, which will be mutilated dogs. Achilles inspires his troops to fight for and with him, while Hector fought Greece... Mythology heroes strived for fame and kept their honor is Achilles and Hector are both leaders of men including! The General Editorship of professor G. S. Kirk wife and his people Patroclus Hector and! Can find a lot of similarities between them is that Hector was in! When Achilles drove his spear, but both Menelaus and without the help of Aphrodite Paris could died... Their cultures for different reason comparison between achilles and hector wasn’t in his army as Hector pride glory... Praise and great respect due to the glory gained in war as a way of their. The highest honor in his army both try to conform comprehensive and provocative guide epic...

Create Gutenberg Block, Alabama Basketball Schedule 2021-22, 2013 Toyota Matrix Xrs For Sale, Time Spiral Remastered Collector Booster, Canon Mg2525 Airprint, Onedrive On Ipad Not Syncing,